Your ideal mattress depends on a few factors: what works best for your body type, your sleep preferences, your budget, and the mattress brand. Since you spend about one-third of your life sleeping, this isn’t a decision to make lightly. Yet, there seems to be an infinite number of options available, so how do you choose?
In this guide, we’ll compare three of the most trusted names in the industry to help you make an informed decision: Serta, Beautyrest, and Tempur-Pedic. By examining their technology, comfort, and overall performance, we’ll give you a clear picture of which of these best mattress brands might suit your sleep needs. It doesn’t matter whether you prefer memory foam, hybrid support, or traditional innerspring designs—at Idler’s, you can feel confident finding a mattress that fits your lifestyle.
Explore Mattresses at Idler's
Upgrade your sleep experience with a new mattress from leading brands available at Idler's Home, today!
Shop Mattress BrandsSerta Mattresses
Serta has been a household name in the sleep industry for over 90 years. Known for pioneering innovations in comfort and support, Serta mattresses combine advanced memory foam, hybrid coil systems, and cooling technologies to provide personalized sleep experiences. The brand is recognized for creating mattresses that cater to all types of sleepers—back, stomach, or side—while focusing on reducing motion transfer and promoting pressure relief. In 2024, Serta was a Women’s Choice Award winner for “America’s Most Recommended Mattress/Box Spring & Pillow.”
Serta offers a wide range of mattresses that are manufactured in the U.S., including memory foam, hybrid, and innerspring options. Their products feature technologies such as the 5-zone coil support system, Carbon Fiber Memory Foam, and CoolFeel Covers, all designed to enhance comfort and support.
Featured Serta Mattresses
Check out these two standout models from Serta that showcase their commitment to quality and innovation.
➥ Serta iSeries NXG 12” Hybrid Firm Smooth Top Queen Mattress
The Serta iSeries NXG 12” hybrid queen mattress delivers targeted support through its 5-zoned coil system and BestEdge Support, ensuring edge-to-edge stability. High-density NXG Memory Foam contours to your body for deep pressure relief, while the cool-to-the-touch cover and Carbon Fiber Memory Foam actively pull heat away for uninterrupted rest. Motion control is optimized to minimize partner disturbance, making it a solid choice for couples. This firm mattress is ideal for back and stomach sleepers who need consistent support without sacrificing comfort. Responsibly crafted and compatible with most bed frames, this mattress offers immediate cooling, reliable pressure relief, and long-lasting stability at an approachable price point.
➥ Serta iSeries NXG 13.5” Hybrid Plush Smooth Top Split Head Queen Mattress
Designed with side sleepers in mind, the Serta iSeries NXG 13.5” hybrid queen mattress combines plush comfort with advanced support features. Its 5-zoned coil system with BestEdge Support provides targeted support to critical areas like the back and shoulders, while NXG Memory Foam contours deeply for pressure relief. Cooling features, including a CoolFeel Cover and Carbon Fiber Memory Foam, ensure the mattress remains comfortable throughout the night. The split head design allows for compatibility with adjustable bases, enhancing comfort for personalized sleep positions. This plush hybrid mattress balances softness with support, offering a restful experience for side sleepers who prefer a luxurious, cloud-like feel.
Serta remains one of the best mattress brands for their blend of innovation, comfort, and durability, making it a dependable choice for virtually any sleeper.
→ Learn more: Why the TempurPedic King Mattress is Worth It
Beautyrest Mattresses
Beautyrest is synonymous with luxury innerspring and hybrid mattresses, focusing on comfort, support, and temperature regulation. Known for high-quality coil systems and pressure-relieving foams, Beautyrest mattresses have earned a reputation for advanced motion separation, temperature control, and long-lasting performance. Their products cater to a range of sleepers while offering innovative features that enhance rest and recovery.
Beautyrest mattresses include traditional innerspring, hybrid, and premium memory foam models. Their signature technologies, like Pocketed Coil Systems and Sleep Climate features, provide individualized support, minimal motion transfer, and consistent comfort. You can also upgrade the Beautyrest Black lineup, with features like a quilted mattress surface and Triple-Stranded Pocketed Coil Technology for superior support and motion isolation.
Featured Beautyrest Mattresses
The following models illustrate Beautyrest’s commitment to creating sleep experiences that combine luxury with science-backed comfort.
➥ Beautyrest Black Series 1 Pocketed Coil 14.25” Firm Pillow Top Queen Mattress
This Beautyrest Black Series 1 queen mattress is built for those seeking advanced support with a firm, luxurious feel. Its Triple-Stranded Pocketed Coil Technology offers individualized support and excellent motion separation, ideal for couples or light sleepers who are easily disturbed. The mattress features contouring foam for exceptional pressure relief and surface-cooling technology to keep heat away from the body. High-density firm comfort foam ensures long-lasting performance, while the pillow top adds a touch of softness for enhanced comfort. Perfect for back and stomach sleepers, this mattress delivers consistent support with a premium sleep experience assembled in the U.S.
➥ Beautyrest World Class Level Three 14.5” Pocketed Coil Medium Firm Tight Top Queen Mattress
This Beautyrest World Class Level Three queen mattress combines advanced Pocketed Coil Technology with World Class Relief HD Foam for responsive pressure relief. InfiniCool MAX Technology keeps sleepers cool through the night, while SurfaceTouch Gel Memory Foam provides immediate comfort and support. This medium-firm mattress is ideal for back and stomach sleepers seeking a balance of support and softness, minimizing sinking while promoting proper spinal alignment. Motion transfer is virtually eliminated, ensuring undisturbed sleep. Its durable construction and CertiPUR-US–certified materials reflect Beautyrest’s dedication to quality and longevity.
Beautyrest consistently ranks among the best mattress brands for combining luxury, support, and innovative cooling features, making it a reliable choice for those who prioritize comfort and performance.
→ Learn more: Serta Mattress Buying Guide: Types, Sizes, & Prices
Tempur-Pedic Mattresses
Tempur-Pedic is renowned for their proprietary TEMPUR-Material, originally developed by NASA to absorb and distribute pressure. This unique material adapts to your body’s shape, weight, and temperature, delivering unmatched pressure relief and motion cancellation. Tempur-Pedic focuses on hybrid designs that combine innersprings with memory foam to offer optimal support, cooling, and comfort for all types of sleepers.
In 2024, Tempur-Pedic became the most awarded brand in the history of the J.D. Power U.S. Mattress Satisfaction Study, and in 2025, the brand ranked in second place for highest customer satisfaction in both the online purchase and retail purchase segments.
Tempur-Pedic mattresses include TEMPUR-Adapt, TEMPUR-ProAdapt, and TEMPUR-LuxeBreeze collections. They feature technologies designed to reduce partner disturbance, promote spinal alignment, and maintain a consistent sleep temperature.
Featured Tempur-Pedic Mattresses
Now, let’s take a look at two highly regarded models that highlight the brand’s innovative approach to sleep.
➥ Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt 11” Hybrid Medium Tight Top Queen Mattress
Shop this Tempur-Pedic® Mattress
This TEMPUR-Adapt 11” hybrid queen mattress blends individually wrapped coils with TEMPUR-Material for superior support, pressure relief, and motion isolation. Its hybrid construction ensures proper spinal alignment while the premium knit cover provides a cool-to-the-touch surface. This mattress minimizes disturbances caused by partner movement, pets, or children, making it ideal for couples. TEMPUR-Material conforms precisely to your body’s weight and temperature, delivering relief for aches and pains. Perfect for back, stomach, and side sleepers, this mattress offers a balanced medium feel with exceptional durability and comfort for long-term sleep satisfaction.
➥ Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-LuxeBreeze 13” TEMPUR-Material Firm Tight Top Split King Mattress, Includes 2 Pieces
Shop this Tempur-Pedic® Mattress
This TEMPUR-LuxeBreeze 13” split king mattress is engineered with advanced cooling features, including Pure Cool Plus and Ventilated Advanced Relief materials that pull heat away from the body. Its TEMPUR-Material adapts to body shape and weight to deliver unparalleled pressure relief and motion separation. The removable, machine-washable cover features heat-absorbing fibers to maintain a cool sleep surface. Designed for back and stomach sleepers who prefer firm support, this mattress also accommodates split king bases for adjustable comfort. Combining proprietary TEMPUR-Material with hybrid coil support, the LuxeBreeze provides a first-class sleep experience with long-lasting durability.
Tempur-Pedic remains one of the best mattress brands for sleepers seeking advanced pressure relief, motion isolation, and a cooler sleep environment.
→ Learn more: Beautyrest Mattresses Compared: Beautyrest vs Beautyrest Black
When it comes to finding the right sleep solution, comparing features, comfort levels, and materials is key. Serta, Beautyrest, and Tempur-Pedic each offer a unique combination of technology and design that earns them a place among the best mattress brands. By understanding your sleep needs and exploring these options, you can confidently invest in a mattress that delivers long-term comfort, support, and restorative sleep.
Best Mattress Brand FAQs
The best brand of mattress depends on your specific needs, but Serta, Beautyrest, and Tempur-Pedic consistently rank among the best brands of mattresses for their comfort, support, and durability. Each offers unique technologies and designs to suit different sleeping styles and preferences. Testing mattresses in store or reviewing online ratings can help narrow your choices.
Yes, Sealy is a reputable mattress brand known for durable innerspring and memory foam models. It offers good support and comfort, particularly for back and stomach sleepers, though when it comes to determining the best brand mattress, some users may prefer the advanced cooling and pressure relief found in brands like Serta or Tempur-Pedic.
Beautyrest mattresses are manufactured by Simmons Bedding Company, a long-standing sleep brand recognized for quality innerspring and hybrid mattresses. They specialize in advanced coil technologies, motion separation, and temperature management.
You can find the mattress best brands at Idler’s, with five locations along the Central Coast of California. Whether you’re searching for the best memory foam mattress brands, a luxury mattress, or a budget-friendly option, we have a wide selection and a helpful team of experts here to help you compare models.
→ Learn more: How to Choose Between Mattress Stores in San Luis Obispo
Why Trust Idler’s Home?
At Idler’s Home, we believe in providing the highest quality products and service to our community. Over the span of 70 years (and counting), our business has seen successful growth, with over 100 employees and five locations along the central coast of California. Not only do we offer major appliances, quality furniture, and the best mattresses but we also provide hot tubs and swim spas and perform kitchen design services. In addition, our trained professional installers can set up all appliances we sell while our factory-trained technicians service and repair them if they ever break down. Suffice it to say: Idler’s is dedicated to helping you make the vision you have for your home a reality.
Shop Mattresses at Idler’s
Envision the possibilities for your home and shop mattresses online at Idler’s. Our friendly team is always happy to help you compare the best mattress brands — whether you call us, email us, or use our online chat feature. Or better yet, stop by any of our five Central Coast locations to experience the quality of our products yourself. Visit us today!
→ Learn more: 7 Top Mattress Picks for Santa Maria Residents in 2025